Repeat customers placed 80.2% of Wayfair's orders in the second quarter of 2026. Yet home goods retailers as a group kept only 21.4% of their 2023 customers into 2024, according to Bluecore's benchmark of more than 100 retailers. Both numbers are accurate. They measure different things, and that's the trouble with most of the retention figures you'll come across.

Compare your store with the wrong one and your conclusions go wrong with it. A high share of orders from returning customers can hide the fact that most new buyers never come back. An all-retail average of 27.4% can make a skincare brand at 30% feel safe while it trails its own category by more than 11 points, or send a furniture store chasing a target its customers have no reason to hit.

The fix is a like-for-like comparison. This guide sets out ecommerce retention rate benchmarks by industry and shows which one fits your products and purchase cycle. It also covers what brings customers back for another order.

What's the average ecommerce retention rate?

The average ecommerce retention rate was 27.4% in 2024, according to Bluecore's 2025 Customer Growth Benchmarks Report. The report covers more than 100 retailers across seven categories, using purchasing data from the 2024 calendar year. It measures the share of the previous year's buyers who continue buying in the following year.

That means roughly a quarter of one year's buyers bought again the next year. The longer view is more sobering. Only 6% of new buyers were still buying three years later:

27.4%

Average annual retention, the share of one year's buyers who buy again the next

Bluecore

6%

Share of new buyers still purchasing three years later

Bluecore

Bluecore's 2025 report is still the edition on its benchmarks page in October 2026, and it's the most widely cited retention benchmark. Other datasets count repeat business in different ways, so check what a figure measures before you compare your store with it:

BenchmarkWhat it measuresFigure
Bluecore annual retention, 2024 dataShare of one year's buyers who buy again the next, across more than 100 retailers27.4%
Bluecore long-term retention, 2024 dataShare of new buyers still buying three years later6%
BS&Co repeat purchase rate, February 2026Share of 156,110 DTC customers who placed a second order within a year18.8%
Wayfair returning customer share, Q2 2026Share of a quarter's orders placed by repeat customers80.2%

The BS&Co figure is a useful second reference for DTC brands, though it's a repeat purchase rate rather than an annual retention rate. BS&Co's February 2026 analysis of 156,110 customers of its DTC client brands found that only 18.8% placed a second order within a year. Wayfair's figure answers a different question altogether: how much of a business runs on existing customers, rather than how many of them come back. Our customer retention rate guide explains how each measure is calculated.

Ecommerce retention rates by industry

Annual retention rates vary widely by retail category, from 41.2% in health and beauty to 19.1% in jewelry and accessories in Bluecore's 2024 data. Every category below uses the same annual measure, so you can compare them directly:

Annual customer retention rate by retail category

Share of 2023 buyers who bought again in 2024

  1. Health and beauty41.2%
  2. Department stores36.2%
  3. Apparel31.7%
  4. Sports and hobbies27.8%
  5. Footwear22.2%
  6. Home goods21.4%
  7. Jewelry and accessories19.1%
Source: Bluecore 2025 Customer Growth Benchmarks

The gap widens over time. Bluecore found that 15% of health and beauty retailers' new customers were still buying three years later, compared with 3% in jewelry and accessories.

Your products create the opportunities for repeat purchases. Someone who finds a moisturizer they like can keep ordering it throughout the year. A necklace or a new sofa is a different kind of purchase, with a longer gap before the customer needs something similar again.

Catalog breadth matters too. A customer might return to a department store for a completely different need, while a brand selling one specialist product has fewer natural reasons to bring that person back.

DTC data points the same way. In BS&Co's client data, brands selling consumables had the highest repeat purchase rates and durables the lowest:

Product typeExamples in BS&Co's dataRepeat purchase rate within a yearTypical rate
ConsumablesSupplements, food and drink, spirits and disposable goods22% to 44%30% to 40%
FashionApparel, jewelry, beauty and luxury10% to 17%12% to 17%
Durables and general retailHome decor and general retail7% to 18%10% to 15%

BS&Co groups beauty with fashion and luxury, where Bluecore gives health and beauty a category of its own, so the two datasets don't line up category by category. They agree on the broad pattern: everyday consumables bring customers back far more often than durable, occasional purchases.

Even within a category, your mix of products makes a difference. A home goods store selling candles and kitchen essentials will have a different buying cycle from one focused on large furniture. The closest useful comparison is a business with a similar role in its customers' lives.

What's a good ecommerce retention rate?

A good ecommerce retention rate is one that beats the average for your category and keeps improving for comparable groups of your own customers. Across all retailers, that means keeping more than 27.4% of last year's buyers. A health and beauty brand needs more than 41.2% to beat its category, while a jewelry store keeping 25% is already well ahead of its category's 19.1%.

Where your target should sit depends on what you sell and how long you've been selling it:

  • Health, beauty and other replenishable products. Aim above the 41.2% health and beauty average, and watch second orders closely in the first 90 days, when most repeat purchases happen. Individual brands can go well beyond the averages: French skincare brand Yon-Ka Paris built a 50% repeat purchase rate without relying on discounts, as its global ecommerce director, Raphael Faccarello, explained on our podcast.
  • Apparel and footwear. Compare with 31.7% for apparel or 22.2% for footwear, and judge each season against the same season a year earlier.
  • Home goods, furniture and jewelry. Annual rates around 20% are normal, so beating 21.4% in home goods or 19.1% in jewelry is a solid result. Referrals and purchases for another room or occasion count for more here than reorders.
  • Stores less than a year old. You don't have an annual retention rate yet. Track how many first-time customers come back within your normal buying window, then compare with BS&Co's one-year ranges once customers have had a full year.

Your own history is the most useful comparison of all, because it holds your products, prices and customers constant. Being above an average is encouraging, but the more useful question is whether you're keeping more of the customers your business is built to serve. Three things shape that target.

Your customers' normal buying cycle

Your customers' normal buying cycle decides which retention window tells you the most. Most repeat purchases happen quickly: in BS&Co's analysis of 40,397 DTC repeat buyers, half placed their second order within 30 days of the first, and 76.4% within 90 days. If your repeat buyers usually return within six to eight weeks, a 90-day second-purchase rate is a strong fit for judging changes quickly.

For seasonal or expensive products, a longer window will be more informative. A winter sports retailer might need to look across successive seasons before deciding whether a customer relationship has continued. NAADAM sells products people don't buy every month, and its chief revenue officer, Sarah Sathaye, explained on our podcast how seasonal pop-up stores lift engagement and order frequency for the brand.

Keep the benchmark comparison annual, and use shorter windows to manage the work that happens along the way. Our customer retention rate guide matches the measure and window to each kind of store, with worked examples.

The customers you're bringing in

The customers your marketing brings in shape your retention rate before any follow-up begins. A first order can come from a future regular, a gift buyer or someone interested only in a clearance deal, and each has a different reason for shopping with you.

Group new customers by their first product and acquisition offer. You might find that a smaller campaign attracts buyers who return more often than the audience from your largest promotion. That can change which products you feature and how you follow up after the sale.

It also helps explain shifts in your overall numbers. A busy gifting season can produce strong sales without producing the same repeat behavior as a replenishment campaign.

The value of repeat orders

A retention rate tells you whether customers return, but not what their repeat orders are worth.

A brand with a modest repeat rate may earn substantial value from a smaller group of frequent buyers. Another may bring many customers back for one deeply discounted order, then struggle to retain them beyond that.

Looking at customer lifetime value helps you connect retention to the amount customers spend and the contribution left after serving them. Together, those measures give you a more useful basis for deciding how much to invest in repeat business.

What makes customers buy again?

Good deals are the most common reason shoppers buy from a brand again, though product quality, fair prices and delivery aren't far behind. In Attentive's January 2026 survey of 600 US adults, 52% named good deals or promotions:

Why shoppers buy from a brand again

Share of US shoppers naming each reason, January 2026

  1. Good deals or promotions52%
  2. Great product quality45%
  3. Free or fast shipping38%
  4. Prices feel fair for what I get38%
  5. Great customer service25%
  6. Easy returns or exchanges22%
  7. Exclusive loyalty program offers18%
  8. Easy shopping experience16%
Source: Attentive 2026 State of Loyalty and Retention

The same survey asked what would make shoppers less likely to go back after a first purchase: prices that felt too high for the value (45%), low product quality (41%) and poor customer service (34%). Most of those are decided by the first order, long before any win-back email goes out.

Deals don't have to mean deep discounts. Andrew Maff, founder of BlueTuskr, explained on our podcast why steep BFCM discounts often backfire, and what to offer instead, from loyalty systems that don't implode margins to smart subscription tactics.

Loyalty programs can help, though few large stores run one. Across 10,766 active programs on its platform, Smile.io's July 2026 data shows members worth 72% more than non-members and buying 47% more often:

+72%

Customer value of loyalty members compared with non-members, median across 10,766 programs

Smile.io

79%

Share of Shopify Plus stores that run no dedicated loyalty program

Smile.io

Treat the first figure with some care: customers who join a program were often more engaged to begin with. Still, the gap between members and everyone else is large enough to justify testing a program built around your best customers. A points program is best suited to stores whose customers already buy several times a year. A moisturizer gives someone enough orders to earn a reward; a sofa usually doesn't.

How to improve your ecommerce retention rate

The best place to start improving your ecommerce retention rate is the point where customers have a reason to leave or a reason to return. That might be a problem with the first order, a missed replenishment opportunity or a shopping experience that makes a repeat purchase harder than it needs to be.

Make the first order worth repeating

Making the first order worth repeating starts with what customers experience between placing it and using the product. Clear delivery expectations, accurate product information and easy access to support all help the purchase live up to its promise.

Then look for recurring complaints. If shoppers regularly struggle with fit, instructions or a particular component, fix that issue before trying to persuade them to buy again. A customer who gets the result they expected has a much stronger reason to return.

Small personal touches count as well. MASC has built an 18-year men's skincare and grooming business on service and trust, from handwritten thank-you notes to one-to-one recommendations, as co-founder Patrick Levesque explained on our podcast.

Build follow-ups around what customers bought

Post-purchase follow-ups work best when they match what the customer bought. Someone who bought a starter kit may need guidance on using it, while someone who bought a refill may simply need a reminder when it's running low.

Use those differences to shape your post-purchase messages. A helpful sequence might begin with product advice, then introduce a relevant next purchase once the customer has had time to use the first one.

The timing should come from your product and order history. Sending every customer the same offer a week after delivery can miss both groups: some won't need it yet, while others needed help sooner.

Make reordering easy

Customers shouldn't have to search your whole catalog to buy the same product again, and most second orders are exactly that: in BS&Co's data, 77% of second purchases were a reorder of the same product. A clear link to their previous item, a saved preference or a convenient reorder option can remove unnecessary effort.

The checkout still matters on a second visit. A simpler checkout experience helps returning shoppers complete their order without repeating steps they've already taken.

Subscriptions are best suited to products customers use at a steady rate, such as coffee, supplements and pet food. Chewy shows how far that can go: sales to customers on its Autoship subscription made up 84.6% of net sales in its fiscal second quarter, which ended August 2, 2026. Give subscribers a cadence that matches their usage and an easy way to change it.

Give regular customers a reason to stay involved

A loyalty program can reward repeat purchases with something customers value, whether that's a useful discount, early access or a product perk. The reward should be understandable and reachable within a realistic number of orders.

If you're considering one, our Shopify loyalty program guide walks through reward design and setup. The same principle applies beyond points: acknowledge the customer's history and make the next interaction relevant to it.

An app can play that role too. Isaac Lewin of Country Life Natural Foods explained on our podcast how the brand launched a mobile app its customers had been asking for, and how that app now supports everything from repeat purchase rates to its growing Country Life Plus membership.

How do you track retention progress?

To track retention progress, choose a measure that matches the change you're making. For a new post-purchase sequence, track second purchases within your normal buying window. For a broader retention effort, compare annual retention alongside spending per customer.

In Shopify, the Customer cohort analysis report groups customers by the date of their first order and shows their later purchasing activity, which makes it a practical starting point. Shopify's customer reports guide explains the available views.

Keep a simple record of each customer group, the change you introduced and the result after a consistent amount of time. If January's buyers have had 90 days to return, compare them with other groups that have also had a full 90 days.

You don't need to change everything at once. A focused improvement is easier to evaluate, and the result gives you a clearer basis for what to do next.

Final thoughts

Retention benchmarks help you understand where your store stands, but your products and customers explain what you can do about it. The most useful target is one that reflects how people buy from you and where there's a realistic opportunity to bring more of them back.

As you improve the experience around those repeat purchases, the numbers become easier to interpret. You can see which changes help customers return, which relationships grow over time and where your retention work is making a difference.

Frequently asked questions

Is a 30% retention rate good for ecommerce?

A 30% annual retention rate beats the 27.4% all-retail average in Bluecore's 2024 data, but whether it's good depends on your category. It's well ahead of the averages for footwear, home goods and jewelry, and just under apparel's 31.7%. For a health and beauty brand, 30% is more than 11 points below the category's 41.2%.

How do you calculate your ecommerce retention rate?

To calculate your ecommerce retention rate, divide the number of last year's customers who bought again this year by the number of customers you had last year, then multiply by 100. If 600 of 2,000 customers return, your annual retention rate is 30%. Leave out customers you acquired this year, and see our customer retention rate guide for the cohort and subscription versions of the formula.

Why is your ecommerce retention rate falling?

A falling ecommerce retention rate often reflects a change in who you're acquiring rather than a worse customer experience. A busy gifting season or a deep-discount campaign can bring in buyers with little reason to return, so compare retention by first product and acquisition offer before rebuilding your post-purchase journey. If those groups hold steady, look at value for money, product quality and customer service, the three things shoppers told Attentive would most likely stop them going back after a first purchase.

Do bigger brands have better retention?

Bigger brands tend to earn more of their revenue from returning customers, though that isn't quite the same as a higher retention rate. In Triple Whale's BFCM 2025 data, returning customers generated 54.69% of revenue for brands with $10 million or more in sales, compared with 33.95% for brands under $1 million. Smaller brands simply have fewer past customers to sell to, so new-customer growth carries more of the load.

How many lapsed customers can you win back?

Retailers won back an average of 7.3% of their lapsed customers in 2024, according to Bluecore, and health and beauty retailers about 14%. Win-back campaigns can still pay off: Nate Okonkwo, co-founder and CEO of Remarkable AI, described on our podcast how a beauty retailer generated $26,000 by reaching just 1,500 customers. Our customer retention statistics break reactivation down by category.