Read a few ecommerce agency homepages in a row and the promises start to blur. Tinuiti's reads "Love growth. Hate waste." Common Thread Collective calls itself an "ecommerce profit partner", and Fuel Made says it improves conversion rate, average order value and lifetime value. Swap the logos and most of those lines would still fit.
The differences sit underneath, and they're large. One of those three says it manages $4 billion in digital media; another works only on Shopify and Klaviyo and says its clients are Shopify brands doing $20 million to $50 million a year. Hire on the pitch alone and the mismatch may only show up once you're paying the retainer.
This guide compares leading ecommerce growth agencies on where each is based, what it does, the brands it works with and the client results it publishes. After the profiles you'll find where they overlap, which to start with for your need, the questions and red flags that matter before you sign and how to read an agency case study.
Which ecommerce growth agencies are worth considering?
The ecommerce growth agencies worth considering depend on the problem you need solved. Common Thread Collective ties ad spend to a profit forecast, Tinuiti runs media across DTC, Amazon and retail, and Power Digital covers the widest spread of marketing and data services. Groove Commerce and Fuel Made combine store design and development with email and other marketing, on BigCommerce and Shopify respectively.
"Based in" is the headquarters or first office each agency's website lists, and "Works with" uses the agency's own description of its clients. None of the five publishes its prices.
| Agency | Based in | Main services | Works with | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Common Thread Collective | Costa Mesa, California | Profit forecasting, Meta, Google and TikTok Shop ads, creative, incrementality testing | Ecommerce brands with seven- to nine-figure revenue, mostly DTC | DTC brands that want ad spend tied to a profit plan |
| Tinuiti | New York, with an office in Mexico City | Amazon and retail media, streaming TV, social, search, measurement | Consumer and B2B brands of all sizes, with a Foundation offering for startups and SMBs | Brands selling through DTC, Amazon and retailers at once |
| Groove Commerce | Baltimore, with offices in Philadelphia, Austin and Orlando | BigCommerce and Shopify builds, B2B ecommerce, SEO, paid media, email and SMS | Mid-market and enterprise retailers, B2C and B2B | Store builds and migrations with marketing from the same team |
| Power Digital | San Diego, with offices in New York, Atlanta and Medellín | Paid media, Amazon and TikTok Shop, SEO, email and SMS, data and measurement, creative | Consumer, CPG, fashion, healthcare and B2B brands | One agency for many channels plus the data behind them |
| Fuel Made | Colbert, Washington | Shopify design and development, Klaviyo email and SMS, conversion rate optimization | Shopify and Shopify Plus brands doing $20 million to $50 million a year | Shopify brands improving conversion and repeat purchases |
Size varies as much as focus. Tinuiti says it has more than 1,000 employee owners, while Fuel Made's about page shows a team of 22. The other three don't publish a headcount, so ask how many people would work on your account.
A closer look at the five agencies
Each profile below covers what the agency does, the brands it works with and one or two client results it publishes. The results are the agency's own account; we haven't audited them, and the section on case studies explains what to ask about each.
1. Common Thread Collective

Common Thread Collective (CTC) is a Costa Mesa, California, agency for ecommerce brands with seven- to nine-figure revenue. Its main offering, the Prophit Engine, pairs one named "Prophit Engineer", who owns the forecast and the daily execution, with CTC's own software and a support team of data scientists, engineers and specialists. The hands-on work covers Meta, Google and TikTok Shop ads, ad creative and incrementality testing.
What sets it apart is that spend is planned against a forecast combining revenue, marketing and cost data, tracked daily against target. That helps if you have plenty of ad reports but no clear answer to how much you can afford to spend, the gap our guide to contribution margin covers. In October 2026 its site was promoting a free Black Friday Bootcamp for this year's season.
Several of CTC's case studies are tests of a single ad channel. For the eyewear brand Quay, it reports 40% higher ROAS in the fourth quarter from Snapchat dynamic product ads than from non-dynamic campaigns run at the same time, at a 31% lower cost per purchase. For UAG, it set up a Google lift study and reports a 13.6% relative lift in sales volume from Demand Gen campaigns. It's best suited to DTC brands whose main growth lever is paid social and search, and that want one accountable person tying that spend to profit.
- Based in: Costa Mesa, California
- Services: Growth planning and forecasting, Meta, Google and TikTok Shop ads, ad creative, incrementality testing
- Works with: Ecommerce brands with seven- to nine-figure revenue, mostly DTC
- Best for: DTC brands that want ad spend tied to a profit forecast, with one named owner
2. Tinuiti

Tinuiti is a media agency that began as the New York search firm Elite SEM in 2004, took its current name in 2019 and grew through acquisitions, including CPC Strategy for Amazon, Bliss Point Media for streaming and Ampush for social, according to its about page. It says it has $4 billion in digital media under management. Its services span Amazon and commerce media, streaming TV, audio and display, Meta and TikTok, paid search and AI SEO, plus affiliate, creative, conversion optimization, email and SMS.
Measurement sits at the center. Its Bliss Point system connects audience, creative, media and measurement, and on October 6, 2026 Tinuiti announced a Bliss Point MCP server that gives a brand's chosen AI tools governed access to that cross-channel performance data. Smaller brands can come in through Foundation, which it describes as its offering for startups and SMBs ready to scale.
For DSW, Tinuiti ran a Meta conversion lift test with a 30% holdout, optimizing for online and offline purchases together. Its case study reports a 16% lift in revenue and says the approach raised ROAS by 15% compared with DSW's usual online-only optimization. Compared with Power Digital, which also spans many channels, Tinuiti leans further into retail and streaming media, making it a strong fit when your products sell on Amazon and in stores as well as on your own site.
- Based in: New York, with an office in Mexico City
- Services: Amazon and commerce media, streaming TV, audio and display, social, search, affiliate, creative, CRO, email and SMS, measurement
- Works with: Apparel, beauty, food and beverage, home services and B2B brands, plus startups and SMBs through Foundation
- Best for: Brands that need media and measurement across DTC, Amazon and retailers
3. Groove Commerce

Groove Commerce is a Baltimore agency founded in 2007 by its owner and CEO, Ethan Giffin, with further offices in Philadelphia, Austin and Orlando. It builds and runs stores for mid-market and enterprise retailers: design, development (migrations, integrations and custom themes), B2B ecommerce, and support and maintenance, plus SEO, paid media, and email and SMS. It's an Elite BigCommerce partner that also works on Shopify, and it hosts the eCommerce Masters Podcast.
Its published work leans on BigCommerce. For Dippin' Dots, Groove built a new store with a shipping calendar in checkout, so customers could pick a delivery date and see blackout dates and costs, and its case study reports revenue up 47% and conversion rate up 13% year over year. For the US Open Shop, it redesigned the tournament's existing store in roughly three months before the event and reports conversion rate up 35% and online orders up 21%, without stating a baseline.
Groove is a strong fit when a marketing problem is partly a storefront problem, or when wholesale and other business buyers need to order online alongside retail customers. Having developers and marketers in one team means the people driving traffic can also change what visitors find when they arrive.
- Based in: Baltimore, Maryland, with offices in Philadelphia, Austin and Orlando
- Services: Ecommerce design and development, migrations, B2B ecommerce, SEO, paid media, email and SMS, support and maintenance
- Works with: Mid-market and enterprise retailers, B2C and B2B, mostly on BigCommerce
- Best for: Store builds, replatforming and B2B ecommerce with marketing from the same team
4. Power Digital

Power Digital is a San Diego growth marketing agency with offices in New York, Atlanta and Medellín, Colombia. It calls itself AI-native: in August 2026 it announced Omega, an AI operating system in which agents monitor client accounts and carry out actions a strategist approves. Its services fall into growth marketing (paid social and search, Amazon, TikTok, programmatic, affiliate, influencer, PR, SEO, generative engine optimization, email and SMS, CRO), data intelligence (measurement, incrementality, marketing mix modeling and data infrastructure), consulting and creative.
Its newest move is into marketplaces. In September 2026 it acquired pirawna and uptickk, agencies specializing in Amazon and TikTok Shop, and now pitches end-to-end commerce across DTC, Amazon and TikTok Shop. Among its own case studies, Power Digital reports that the snack brand Catalina Crunch saw Amazon revenue rise 47% and Instacart revenue 144% year over year after a full-funnel retail program, and it credits its digital work with $1.3 million in extra sales in physical stores.
It's best suited to brands that want one agency to coordinate many channels and the data behind them, especially consumer brands selling through retailers and marketplaces as well as their own store. With that much breadth, ask which specialists would actually staff your account and how much of the work runs through Omega.
- Based in: San Diego, California, with offices in New York, Atlanta and Medellín
- Services: Paid media, Amazon and TikTok Shop, SEO and GEO, influencer and affiliate, email and SMS, CRO, measurement and data infrastructure, creative
- Works with: B2B, consumer services, CPG, fashion, healthcare and lifestyle brands (its six divisions)
- Best for: Brands that want many channels and measurement coordinated by one agency
5. Fuel Made

Fuel Made does three things: Shopify design and development, Klaviyo email and SMS, and conversion rate optimization. It has been a Shopify partner since 2011, holds Shopify Plus Partner and Klaviyo Master Elite status, and its site lists Colbert, Washington, as its location. A September 2026 guide on its site says it works with Shopify and Shopify Plus brands doing $20 million to $50 million a year, and its about page lists categories from skincare and haircare to pet supplies, apparel and home furnishings.
Its case studies show both halves of the work. For the supplement brand Smidge, a client for nearly a decade, Fuel Made planned 18 fourth-quarter email and SMS touchpoints built on education rather than hard selling, and reports campaign revenue up 194% and campaign orders up 182% on the previous holiday season. A redesign for The Office Oasis, which sells rollerblade-style office chair wheels, is credited with a 59% higher desktop conversion rate and 62% higher mobile conversion rate, against an unstated baseline.
It's ideal for Shopify brands that want more revenue from the traffic and customers they already have, with the store and the lifecycle emails planned together. If repeat purchases are the goal, agree up front how you'll measure retention itself, not just email revenue.
- Based in: Colbert, Washington
- Services: Shopify design and development, Klaviyo email and SMS, CRO audits and A/B testing
- Works with: Shopify and Shopify Plus brands doing $20 million to $50 million a year
- Best for: Shopify brands improving conversion, average order value and repeat purchases
Which ecommerce agencies overlap?
Common Thread Collective, Tinuiti and Power Digital all buy paid media, while Groove Commerce and Fuel Made both build stores. Two ecommerce agencies from the same row below make a fair comparison; two from different rows are solving different problems.
| Job | Agencies | How they differ |
|---|---|---|
| Paid social and search | Common Thread Collective, Tinuiti, Power Digital | CTC plans spend against a profit forecast; Tinuiti adds streaming and retail media at scale; Power Digital adds PR, influencer and affiliate |
| Amazon and marketplaces | Tinuiti, Power Digital, Common Thread Collective | Tinuiti's Amazon practice dates from its CPC Strategy acquisition; Power Digital bought pirawna and uptickk in September 2026; CTC covers TikTok Shop |
| Store design and development | Groove Commerce, Fuel Made | Groove's published work is mostly on BigCommerce and includes B2B; Fuel Made works only on Shopify |
| Email and SMS | Fuel Made, Groove Commerce, Tinuiti, Power Digital | Fuel Made and Groove tie it to store changes; Tinuiti and Power Digital fold it into a wider media program |
| Measurement and incrementality | Common Thread Collective, Tinuiti, Power Digital | CTC builds it into each forecast; Tinuiti runs it through Bliss Point; Power Digital sells it as a data intelligence service |
Which agency should you start with?
The right agency to call first depends on the problem you most need solved. Pick the row that matches your biggest constraint, and talk to a second agency from the same row before you decide.
| If you need… | Start with |
|---|---|
| A profit forecast behind your ad spend | Common Thread Collective |
| Media across Amazon, retailers, streaming and DTC | Tinuiti |
| A new store, a replatform or B2B ordering online | Groove Commerce |
| Many marketing channels plus data work from one team | Power Digital |
| Better Shopify conversion and Klaviyo flows | Fuel Made |
| Growth on Amazon or TikTok Shop | Tinuiti or Power Digital |
How do you choose an ecommerce growth agency?
Choosing an ecommerce growth agency comes down to four things: a clear problem, the people who'll do the work, terms you understand and evidence you can check. Once you have a shortlist, the most useful conversations are about your business rather than the agency's credentials.
What problem should an agency solve for you?
An agency brief that says only "we want to grow" leaves too much room for interpretation. You may need more first-time buyers, better conversion from existing traffic or more revenue from returning customers, and those call for different agencies: a media agency for the first, a store and CRO agency for the second, a lifecycle specialist for the third.
If the problem is repeat purchasing, for example, look beyond the number of emails an agency promises to send. The discussion should include your product's buying cycle, the customer experience and how the team would measure customer retention.
Questions to ask before you sign
Ask every agency on your shortlist the same questions, so the answers are comparable:
- Who will work on our account each week, and how many other accounts do they handle?
- What will you do in the first 90 days, and what will you need from our team?
- Which metric will you be judged on, and what's the baseline?
- Who owns the ad accounts, the store code, the email platform, the data and the creative if we part ways?
- What does the fee include: creative production, development hours, software?
- What's the minimum term, the notice period and the exit route if results fall short?
- Which brands like ours have you worked with, and can we speak to one of them?
It also helps to talk through an ordinary week: who spots a problem, who approves a change, who produces the assets and who ships them. The answers show whether the engagement adds capacity where you need it.
Red flags to watch for
The warning signs in an agency pitch are usually about accountability rather than skill:
- Results quoted without a baseline, a period or a way to check them.
- A senior team in the pitch and no clear answer about who runs the account after you sign.
- Ad accounts, pixels or data set up in the agency's name instead of yours.
- Reporting only on platform ROAS, with no view of margin, new customers or incrementality.
- A long lock-in with no exit tied to performance.
- A full plan presented before the agency has seen your numbers.
Vetting is the subject of our podcast conversation with Chris Brewer, co-founder of OMG Commerce, who walks through the steps that matter when choosing an agency and the red flags brands most often overlook.
How do you judge an agency's case studies?
An agency case study is only as useful as the comparison behind it. The eight results quoted in this guide show how much that varies.
| Agency and client | Result the agency reports | Compared with |
|---|---|---|
| Common Thread Collective for Quay | 40% higher ROAS in Q4 | Non-dynamic Snapchat campaigns run at the same time |
| Common Thread Collective for UAG | 13.6% relative lift in sales volume | A Google lift study; baseline values not given |
| Tinuiti for DSW | ROAS up 15% | DSW's usual online-only Meta optimization, in a test with a 30% holdout |
| Groove Commerce for Dippin' Dots | Revenue up 47%, conversion rate up 13% | The previous year; months not stated |
| Groove Commerce for US Open Shop | Conversion rate up 35%, online orders up 21% | Not stated |
| Power Digital for Catalina Crunch | Amazon revenue up 47%, Instacart revenue up 144% | The previous year; period not stated |
| Fuel Made for Smidge | Campaign revenue up 194% | The previous holiday season |
| Fuel Made for The Office Oasis | Desktop conversion rate up 59% | Not stated |
Three of the eight come from tests run against a comparison group at the same time (Quay, UAG and DSW), three compare with the previous year and two give no comparison at all. A missing baseline doesn't make a result wrong, but a year-over-year gain can come from a new product, a bigger budget or a market that grew anyway. Ask what changed, what the agency did, what the client's own team contributed and what the numbers were before.
A case study is also more informative when the starting conditions resemble yours. Similar products, margins, purchase cycles and channel mixes make it easier to judge whether the same approach would work for your brand.
What does an agency really cost?
An agency's real cost is its fee plus the media spend, software and internal time the work depends on. One proposal may include creative production and implementation; another may assume your team provides both, so compare the work included, not just the monthly number.
Judge the total against your margins rather than revenue, because a fee that looks small against sales can still absorb most of the profit from the extra orders it brings in. Abir Syed, co-founder of UpCounting and a former performance marketing agency owner, explains in our episode on brands that look profitable but are broke why growing brands can look healthy while struggling with cash flow. Your LTV to CAC ratio is a useful check on whether newly acquired customers will pay back what they cost.
Final thoughts
The right ecommerce growth agency brings expertise and capacity to a problem your business needs solved. These five show how different that can look: a profit forecast with one accountable engineer at CTC, retail, streaming and social media with its own measurement system at Tinuiti, store builds with marketing at Groove Commerce and Fuel Made, and a wide, data-led program at Power Digital.
Use this list to start focused conversations, not to pick a winner. When both sides agree on the problem, who does the work, how results are measured and what happens if they don't arrive, you have a much better foundation for the relationship.
Frequently asked questions
How do ecommerce agencies charge for their work?
Ecommerce agencies usually charge a monthly retainer, a percentage of ad spend, a fixed project fee or a mix of these, sometimes with a performance bonus. None of the five agencies here publishes its prices, so expect a proposal after a discovery call. Retainers suit ongoing work such as email and CRO, project fees suit a site build or migration, and a percentage of spend ties the fee to budget rather than results, so ask how it changes as spend grows.
How long is an ecommerce agency contract?
Ecommerce agency contract terms vary, and none of the agencies on this list publishes a standard minimum. Before you sign, ask for the minimum term, the notice period and any early exit tied to performance. Project work such as a store migration has its own end point, and agencies like Groove Commerce sell ongoing support and maintenance as a separate service.
Should you hire an agency or build an in-house team?
An agency usually makes more sense than an in-house hire when you need several specialists part time, or expertise you'll only need for a project. An in-house team makes more sense once a channel is big and steady enough to keep a specialist busy full time and depends on daily knowledge of your products and customers. You can also combine the two, with an internal owner who sets goals and approves work while the agency adds capacity.
Can you work with more than one agency at once?
You can work with more than one agency, and it often makes sense when their jobs don't overlap, such as a store agency like Fuel Made alongside a media agency like Tinuiti. Agree who owns which metric and which accounts, and report from one shared set of numbers so two agencies aren't both claiming the same sales.
What's the difference between a growth agency and a performance marketing agency?
A performance marketing agency mainly buys and optimizes paid media against targets like ROAS or cost per acquisition, while a growth agency takes a wider brief that can include the store, retention, creative and forecasting. The labels overlap in practice: Tinuiti calls itself a media agency, Power Digital a growth marketing agency and Common Thread Collective a profit partner. Judge the scope written into the proposal rather than the label.




