The average US consumer is enrolled in eight loyalty programs but actively participates in only five, according to Deloitte's survey of 5,564 loyalty program members. Much of what members earn goes unused, too: 27% of the loyalty points customers earned in 2025 were left unspent, Antavo found. For many shoppers, a loyalty program is an account they opened once and stopped thinking about.
At the other end of the scale, the program is simply how customers shop. Ulta Beauty's loyalty program has more than 46 million members, who generated about 95% of the retailer's total sales in fiscal 2025, according to its annual report. At Starbucks, Rewards members accounted for 59% of spending in its US company-operated stores in the quarter to June 2026.
The research on this page helps explain the gap between those two pictures. It brings together the latest customer loyalty statistics for 2026: how loyal shoppers really are, how many programs they join, what members want, why they lose interest and how much more they're worth. Each figure comes with a note on what it measures, so you can use the right one whether you're making the case for a program, choosing perks or checking how your own members compare.
How loyal are consumers in 2026?
Consumers are less loyal than businesses tend to think. In PwC's 2025 survey of 5,511 US consumers and 406 executives, about nine in 10 executives said customer loyalty had grown in recent years. Only four in 10 consumers said the same.
Shoppers are also quick to experiment. In Attentive's January 2026 survey of 600 US shoppers, 88% had bought from a brand new to them in the past three months. Yet 77% said they regularly shop with five brands or fewer, and only 18% expected to buy again from most or all of the new brands they'd tried. People try lots of brands, but they settle on a small group.
88%
US shoppers who bought from a brand new to them in the past three months
77%
Shoppers who regularly buy from five brands or fewer
52%
US consumers who stopped buying from a brand after a bad product or service experience
Loyalty is also easy to lose, and the product matters most. In the same PwC survey, 52% of consumers said they had stopped using or buying from a brand after a bad experience with its products or services, compared with 29% who stopped because of a poor customer experience online or in a store. Sophia Legros, VP of product integrity, social compliance and sustainability, argued on our podcast that retention starts at the source, in how products are made and sourced, long before the first email or loyalty program.
Do loyalty programs increase customer loyalty?
Loyalty program members say programs keep them coming back. In Bond's survey of 20,591 US loyalty program members, conducted between January and March 2026, 85% said they're more likely to keep doing business with a brand that has a loyalty program, and 73% said they spend more because of it.
Deloitte's survey, conducted in September and October 2025, found a similar effect, with a gap between intention and action: 72% of loyalty members said programs make them more likely to spend with their preferred brand, but 56% said they actually increase their spending because of a program. Among 4,000 US and UK members of ecommerce loyalty programs surveyed by LoyaltyLion in March 2026, 90% said membership influences them to buy from the same brand again, up from 85% in 2024.
Platform data shows members spending more too. Taking the median across 10,766 active loyalty programs on its platform, Smile.io found that members were worth 72% more than non-members and bought 47% more often, in data published in July 2026. Customers who redeemed a reward were worth 3.1 times as much as those who didn't.
Those figures need some care. Customers who join a program are often more engaged to begin with, and Smile.io notes that members self-select. The gap shows that loyal customers and program members overlap heavily, not that the program created all of the extra spending.
A program also ranks below the basics when shoppers decide which brands to go back to. When Attentive asked what makes shoppers seek out a brand by name, 26% said being a loyalty or rewards member, compared with 56% for product quality and 51% for good value for the price.
How many loyalty programs do consumers belong to?
The number of loyalty programs a consumer belongs to ranges from about three to more than 17, depending on which programs are counted:
| Source | What it counts | Average programs per person |
|---|---|---|
| Bond Loyalty Report, 2025 | Programs of every kind consumers take part in, across more than 20 sectors | 17.4 |
| Deloitte, September to October 2025 | Programs US loyalty members are enrolled in, across industries | 8 enrolled, 5 actively used |
| LoyaltyLion, March 2026 | Programs held by US and UK ecommerce shoppers, excluding travel, utilities, coffee shops and restaurants | 3.05, up from 2.84 a year earlier |
Within a single industry, most people pick one program. In Deloitte's survey, 51% of respondents engaged with only one program in a given industry. The one they choose gets real attention: LoyaltyLion found ecommerce shoppers log in to their favorite program 10 times a month on average, and 54% check its points balance at least once a week.
That's the real competition for a loyalty program: being the one a customer actually uses in your category, rather than one of the many they've signed up for and forgotten.
What do shoppers want from loyalty programs?
Shoppers want practical savings from loyalty programs first, with free or faster shipping at the top of the list. When Attentive asked US shoppers which loyalty perks they want, 65% chose free or faster shipping:
Loyalty program perks US shoppers want, January 2026
Exclusivity matters as well. In the same survey, 41% said VIP-only discounts are the type of offer most likely to keep them shopping with a brand, ahead of rewards based on past purchases (30%). And 81% said seeing their progress toward a reward motivates them.
Bond's research points the same way. For the second year running, "access", such as first looks, last calls and skipping the line, was the top driver of loyalty among the US program members in its 2026 report. Ecommerce members rank savings first but rate access perks almost as highly: in LoyaltyLion's survey, 88% called discounts an important loyalty benefit, followed by member-only pricing (78%), bonus points on specific collections (77%), birthday rewards (76%) and early access to sales (75%).
Perks don't have to be discounts at all. John Roman, CEO of BattlBox, explained on our podcast how the subscription brand keeps customers engaged without loyalty gimmicks or endless discounts, leaning on content, community and surprise-and-delight moments such as $25,000 golden ticket competitions.
Why do loyalty program members lose interest?
Slow rewards are the biggest reason loyalty program members end up disappointed. In Antavo's Global Customer Loyalty Report 2026, which includes a panel of 10,000 loyalty program members worldwide, the top reasons for disappointment with a program were that rewards take too long to earn (49.1%), that rewards expire before they can be used (41.1%) and that the rewards aren't attractive (38.9%).
Some of the biggest programs use faster earning and points that don't expire as rewards for reaching a higher status. On Starbucks Rewards, Green members earn 1 Star per $1 and their Stars expire six months after they're earned. Gold members, who earn 500 or more Stars a year, get 1.2 Stars per $1 and Reserve members (2,500 or more) get 1.7. Neither group's Stars expire while they keep that status.

That frustration shows up in points and rewards left unused:
27%
Loyalty points earned in 2025 that were left unspent
40%
Loyalty members who admit they sometimes forget to redeem rewards
64%
Ecommerce loyalty members who'd stop using a program if rewards took too long to earn
Confusing programs lose members just as fast as slow ones. In LoyaltyLion's survey, 64% of ecommerce loyalty members said they'd stop using a program if it wasn't clear how to earn points or what rewards were available, the same share who'd quit over slow rewards. A missing VIP tier mattered far less:
Ecommerce loyalty members likely to stop using a program, by reason, March 2026
Satisfaction is middling, and brands overestimate it. Only 48% of Americans told Bond they were "very satisfied" with their loyalty program, in its 2025 report. Antavo found that 82.6% of marketers believe their programs make customers feel valued, while only 56.2% of customers agree. Executives have their doubts too: in PwC's 2025 survey, 46% said their company's current loyalty program will be irrelevant in three years.
Loyalty programs by generation
Younger shoppers are the most engaged with loyalty programs. In LoyaltyLion's March 2026 survey, 70% of Gen Z members said they feel more emotionally connected to a brand when they're a loyalty member, compared with 41% of baby boomers:
Ecommerce loyalty members who feel more emotionally connected to a brand as a member
Younger shoppers are also more open to personalization. In Deloitte's survey, 89% of Gen Z and 87% of millennials said they would share personal information for more tailored offers, against 78% of Gen X and 64% of baby boomers. About half of Gen Z (51%) and millennials (53%) said they'd spend more with a brand that offered a personalized experience, while 38% of Gen X and 19% of boomers said the same.
Older members lean toward plain savings. In LoyaltyLion's survey, 74% of boomers and 72% of Gen X joined their last loyalty program to get discounts on future purchases, against 59% of millennials and 53% of Gen Z. Personalized offers and experiences are best suited to brands whose customers skew young, while an older customer base will usually respond more to straightforward savings.
Loyalty programs at scale
At the largest retailers, loyalty members account for most of the business:
95%
Share of Ulta Beauty's fiscal 2025 sales from its 46 million-plus loyalty members
59%
Share of spending at US company-operated Starbucks stores from Rewards members, Q3 fiscal 2026
203M
Estimated US Amazon Prime members, June 2026 quarter, counting individual users
Those shares say as much about enrollment as about extra spending. Ulta reported that loyalty members generated more than 95% of its net sales in fiscal 2019 as well, when it had more than 34 million active members, so the share has held at about 95% while membership grew by roughly 12 million. Once nearly every customer is a member, members' share of sales mostly tells you how many customers have joined.
Starbucks shows the same pattern. It had 35.8 million 90-day active US Rewards members in the quarter to June 2026, up from 33.8 million two years earlier, yet members' share of spending in US company-operated stores edged down from 60% to 59% over the same period, according to its loyalty dashboard. Amazon Prime is a different model again: a paid membership rather than a free points program, which CIRP estimates 203 million individual US shoppers use, a count that includes family members sharing an account.
How many ecommerce brands run a loyalty program?
Most ecommerce brands, even large ones, don't run a dedicated loyalty program. Smile.io, which sells loyalty software, found that 79% of Shopify Plus storefronts don't run one, based on 78,839 Plus storefronts tracked by Store Leads in July 2026. Adoption rises with revenue:
Shopify Plus storefronts running a loyalty program, by estimated annual revenue, July 2026
Share of storefronts in each band running one of six major loyalty platforms
Category matters too. In the same data, 24% of beauty and fitness storefronts on Shopify Plus run a loyalty program, compared with 17% in apparel and in food and drink, and 12% in home and garden. Smile.io ties that pattern to repeat-purchase economics: a program compounds fastest when customers buy often. That makes a loyalty program a stronger fit for categories customers restock, such as beauty, than for occasional purchases like furniture and homewares.
Brands that do run programs are mostly happy with them. In Antavo's survey of 3,000 marketing, IT and loyalty professionals, 83.0% of loyalty program owners said they were satisfied, up from 69.2% a year earlier, and owners allocate 51.5% of their marketing budget to loyalty and CRM. Treat those figures as self-reported by the people running the programs.
Is it true that loyalty members generate 12% to 18% more revenue?
The claim that loyalty members generate 12% to 18% more revenue than non-members comes from a 2016 Accenture survey of 106 US retail loyalty professionals. It reflects what those managers reported about their own programs, not an analysis of sales data, and it's now a decade old. The more recent platform data from Smile.io, along with company figures like Ulta's, is a better guide.
How the main loyalty studies compare
The main customer loyalty studies survey different people in different ways, so the most useful one depends on the question you're asking:
| Study | Who or what it measures | When | Best used for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bond Loyalty Report | 20,591 US loyalty program members | January to March 2026 | What members say about programs across all sectors |
| PwC Customer Experience Survey | 5,511 US consumers and 406 executives | Published September 2025 | The gap between how executives and customers see loyalty |
| Deloitte loyalty survey | 5,564 US loyalty program members | September to October 2025 | Enrollment against active use and generational differences |
| Attentive State of Loyalty and Retention | 600 US adults | January 2026 | Which perks shoppers want and why they return to a new brand |
| LoyaltyLion Loyalty in 2026 | 4,000 US and UK members of ecommerce loyalty programs | March 2026 | Ecommerce-specific habits and why members drop out |
| Antavo Global Customer Loyalty Report | 10,000 members and 3,000 professionals worldwide, plus platform data | Published February 2026 | Program owners' view and unspent points |
| Smile.io State of Loyalty | 10,766 programs on its platform and 78,839 Shopify Plus storefronts | July 2026 | Member value and adoption benchmarks on Shopify |
Survey figures show what members say, which makes them ideal for choosing perks and spotting frustrations. Platform and company data show what members do, so they're better suited to sizing the opportunity, as long as you remember that members self-select. Most of these studies come from loyalty and marketing vendors, so check who published a figure, and what they sell, before you build a business case on it.
What these numbers mean for ecommerce brands
The research points to a few practical lessons for ecommerce brands, whether you're deciding to launch a loyalty program or improving one you already run.
- Make rewards feel reachable. The most common complaint about loyalty programs is that rewards take too long to earn. Showing progress and offering an early, achievable reward keeps members engaged.
- Make the rules easy to follow. Members are as likely to drop a program they don't understand as one that's slow. Explain how to earn and redeem in plain terms, and let members apply rewards at checkout.
- Lead with practical perks. Free shipping, points and member-only offers top shoppers' wish lists. VIP tiers and exclusive content matter less to most people.
- Fix the basics first. Half of consumers have walked away from a brand after a bad product or service experience. No program makes up for that. Our guide to ecommerce retention rates shows what usually brings customers back.
- Measure members carefully. Compare members with similar non-members, such as customers with the same number of past orders, before crediting the program with all of the difference in spending.
If you're on Shopify, our guide to launching a Shopify loyalty program covers how to design the rewards, choose an app and put these findings into practice.
Final thoughts
Customers aren't as loyal as brands like to think, and they're happy to try someone new. But most still settle on a handful of brands they come back to, and the right loyalty program can help make sure yours is one of them.
The programs that work are simple: rewards customers can reach, rules they understand, perks they actually value and a product experience worth returning to.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between customer loyalty and customer retention?
Customer retention measures whether customers buy from you again, while customer loyalty describes why they keep choosing you, even when another brand is cheaper or easier to find. Retention is the number you can track in your order data. Loyalty shows up there as repeat purchases, but also in referrals, reviews and buying without waiting for a sale. Our customer retention statistics cover the behavioral side.
How do you measure customer loyalty?
You measure customer loyalty mainly through behavior: repeat purchase rate, customer retention rate and purchase frequency, plus the share of sales from members and how often they redeem if you run a program. Surveys of satisfaction or likelihood to recommend add the attitude behind those numbers. Our guide to customer retention rate shows how to calculate the most useful behavioral measure, and our guide to customer lifetime value shows how to put a value on it.
Do loyalty programs work for small ecommerce brands?
Loyalty programs can work for small ecommerce brands, but the payoff is much smaller than at scale. In Smile.io's illustrative math, a two-point lift in repeat-purchase share is worth about $400,000 a year to a brand with $20 million in revenue, but about $10,000 at $500,000, which Smile.io notes may not cover the software subscription. Our guide to launching a Shopify loyalty program covers how to start simply.
What happens to loyalty points customers don't use?
Loyalty points customers don't use either stay in their accounts or expire under the program's rules. Among programs that use point expiration, Antavo found that 12% of all points earned expire. Retailers usually defer part of the revenue from a sale until the points are used: Ulta Beauty, for example, recognizes loyalty program revenue when members redeem points or the points expire.
Do loyalty programs work for products people don't buy often?
Loyalty programs can work for products people don't buy often, but a points program is a weaker fit, because customers earn too slowly for rewards to feel reachable. Access, service and experiences don't depend on how often someone buys. Sarah Sathaye, chief revenue officer of NAADAM, explained on our podcast how seasonal pop-up stores lift engagement and order frequency at the brand, alongside its digital channels and loyalty strategies.




